CreativeGraces.net
Genealogical
Research
Index


Home Page & Contact

“The Geneal Geologist”
supporting collaborative family history and DNA research since 1979.
Online since 1998

CreativeGraces.net

- GENEALOGICAL RESEARCH INDEX -

The CONNELL / O'CONNELL Family of Ballyvogue & Ballydehob, County Cork
The GOOD Family of Phale (Ballineen), County Cork
The SHORTEN Family of Moneygaff West, County Cork


This synopsis reviewed and fully updated by “The Geneal Geologist”, November 2016
Additional information, comments and corrections welcome
“My Irish Genealogy” Research Blog

Ø Modern descendants of the CONNELL family include LOWNEY (of Clonakilty, Cork), and MacCAFFREY (of Dublin, Ireland / Perth, Australia & New Zealand).

Ø Many of the GOOD family left West Cork for Nova Scotia, Canada (also many moving on to settle in the US), as well as forming new branches throughout Cork and the UK. There are hundreds of GOOD relations documented on my Ancestry.com tree but not discussed here.

Ø The SHORTEN family has many branches, but is a name localised in West Cork, Ireland.

As the three families share many elements of the same story, it is appropriate to include them all in the same synopsis. Research is continuing.


Part 1: The CONNELL / O'CONNELL Family of Ballyvoge & Ballydehob

The story of the CONNELL family is limited to very few individuals, but contains more than its share of mysteries. The homeplace for my wife’s branch of the family (usually recorded without the O’ until late in the C19th) has been identified as the townland of Ballyvoge (Ballyvouge/Ballyvogue), west of Macroom. Records can also refer to nearby Inchigeelah and Kilnamartyra (parishes and church) and Macroom (regional registration district). The location of the townland relative to Macroom is shown on the map below. There are enough records to indicate that there must have been an extensive CONNELL family in the area, so I would be pleased to hear from anyone who has more information or is related to this family. The family were Roman Catholic.


The current identified heads of the CONNELL family are my wife’s 2xGGPs John CONNELL, a labourer & his wife Mary McCARTHY who married in 1860. The only family witness at the wedding was a Callahan McCARTHY who is possibly the bride’s father (although it is a popular name in the area). Only 4 children are known, without further information on John & Mary. It is possible they emigrated to the US (to explain son Daniel being there in 1899) or remained in the townland:

·    Jeremiah “Jerry” CONNELL (1861);

·    Julia CONNELL (1863);

·    Margaret CONNELL (1865);

·    Daniel CONNELL / O’CONNELL (1867), my wife’s GGF;

The story of Daniel starts with him working in a saloon bar at 106 Market Street in Wilmington, Delaware in the US at the time of his marriage to Gertrude “Gertie” GOOD in April 1899. There is no record of how he came to be in the US and the same relating to Gertrude is discussed under her family. Daniel & Gertrude, were both recorded as being of Irish families. Daniel’s parents were given as s/o John & Mary M O’CONNELL and Gertrude (who was living in Philadelphia, PA) d/o John & Hannah GOOD. Their marriage certificate gives Gertrude as Gertrude H GOOD. Strangely, they are not located in the 1900 Delaware census (taken on 1st June 1900) even though 2 children were born to them that year in Wilmington. The marriage was somewhat unusual in that Daniel was Roman Catholic and Gertie a Protestant (Church of Ireland), and may have only been possible in the US (not Ireland). It is not clear how they came to meet nor their apparent age difference of some 12 years. The couple apparently agreed that any boys would be raised as Catholics and any girls raised as Protestants.

The five children of Daniel & Gertrude O’CONNELL are confirmed as:

·       John O’CONNELL (Jan 1900 - Feb 1900 aged 5 weeks) Wilmington, New Castle, Delaware, US;

·       May O’CONNELL (Nov 1900 - Dec 1900 aged 5 days) Wilmington;

·       Daniel F O’CONNELL (Feb 1902 - Jul 1902 aged 5 months) Wilmington;

·       Edna Elizabeth O'CONNELL (1904 Ballydehob - 1981 Clonakilty) = Timothy “Ted” LOWNEY, my wife’s grandparents;

·       Phyllis Marguerite O'CONNELL (1915 Ballydehob – after 1985 Perth, Australia) = in 1934 Cuckfield, Sussex, England to James Patrick Dillon MacCAFFREY (1914 Liverpool-1942 Dublin). When her sons emigrated, Phyllis followed (Dillon Ronald "Ronnie" MacCAFFREY (registered as Edward R in 1938) & Peter Kenneth MacCAFFREY (1941). The couple also had a daughter Yvonne Ann MacCAFFREY (1937);

Assuming as the result of the premature deaths of their first 3 children, Daniel & Gertie left the US and settled in the up and coming market town of Ballydehob, close to their West Cork roots. At the time, they were local celebrities having arrived on the SS Etruria at Queenstown (Cobh) in Aug 1902 with “their American dollars” and Gertie was sometime referred to as the “American woman”. Daniel was a shopkeeper at 29 Ballydehob in 1911. The middle initial “G” is only found on the 1911 Irish census, the death certificate for his wife and the 1914 trade directory for Ballydehob, which appears to distinguish him (as a poultry dealer) from another Daniel O’CONNELL in Ballydehob (known as “Danlo”, grocer/shopkeeper), without a middle initial. It is suspected that the “G” was for Gertrude, as Daniel’s birth, baptism, marriage and death records only have him as Daniel.



The building on the left in Ballydehob (decorated for St Patrick’s Day with the old shop owners) was DG’s poultry shop. He later ran a pub in the building now occupied by Duggan’s Restaurant (middle building in right photo).


There are people still living (2016) who knew “DG” as children and relate that he was held in high regard by his neighbours and customers. He was described as an old man, very tall and “hefty” with a good head of white/grey hair, who used to greet families on their way home from Mass. He did have a good relationship with his family; they all got on well with each other and the different religions in the household did not seem to make any difference. Gertie worked as a teacher at the local C of I school. Even after the girls grew up and left Ballydehob, they kept in very regular contact with their father. Their mother died in 1923 of TB.

DG retired to Sparrograda, just north of Ballydehob. Today, the nearby junction (Dreenaclough and Sparrograda) on the Bantry road is referred to as “DG’s” even though the house has gone (below). DG tied in 1943 at Schull Hospital.




Other CONNELLs recorded at Ballyvoge, who are probably members of the same family are:

Ø John CONNELL, mentioned in the Tithe Applotment Book for 1826 as farming 13 acres;

Ø Patrick CONNELL, listed in Griffiths Valuation (early 1850’s);

Ø Daniel CONNELL (Agricultural Labourer), present with his family in 1901 & 1911 – wife Anne and

o   Cornelius CONNELL (1883);

o   Michael CONNELL (1887);

o   Patrick CONNELL (1893);

o   Timothy CONNELL (1894);

o   Hannah CONNELL (1896);

o   Mary CONNELL (1898);

Ø Jeremiah “Jerry” CONNELL = Hanora “*Norry” DONOGHUE parents of Daniel who married in 1843;



Part 2: The GOOD Family of Phale (Ballineen), Enniskean, County Cork

My wife’s GGM is Gertrude Hannah GOOD (c1882-1923). As mentioned above, it is not clear how she came to the US for her marriage (whether correctly living in Philadelphia, PA as she stated), and how she met her husband (in Ireland as a child, or the US after living with relatives or having travelling there independently). The marriage was unusual in that it was an RC = C of I match and evidence that seems to suggest she may have lied about her age (given as 19, when possibly only 17 or just turned 18). There was also a 12-year age difference. Gertie’s actual age is not known as her birth record has not been located, although she is known in GOOD family circles as being part of the Ballineen GOOD family. Her age upon death provides a YOB of 1882. Her middle name of Hannah is from her mother, her parents given upon marriage matches her family in Ballineen, and in her last days she was recorded as having died in Ballineen, witnessed by Daniel (despite her home with Daniel O’CONNELL in Ballydehob). She is reportedly buried in the now disused Ballymoney St Paul (C of I) churchyard, Ballineen, but her grave is unmarked. The story of my wife’s branch of the Ballineen GOOD family, who were Protestant Church of Ireland (part of the original C17th English settlers from Devon & Somerset), now follows. The maps show the location of the townland of Phale Upper (townland home of John & Margaret GOOD) relative to the three main towns of Dunmanway, Enniskean & Clonakilty, and the distribution of GOOD at the time of Griffiths Valuation (with a clear concentration on West Cork):

 

The head of my wife’s GOOD family is currently Thomas GOOD, a labourer from Ballineen, probably born c1800. He is assumed to be the one who married Anne COTTER at the original Ballymoney church in 1825, and are my wife’s 2xGGPs. It is not clear how Thomas connects into the greater GOOD families. Nothing is known of Anne’s origins, but is assumed to also be a local girl. Records for C of I in the C19th are poor (missing, destroyed or yet to be indexed), so although Thomas & Anne may have had many children, only two are currently known: sons John GOOD & William GOOD.

John GOOD is only confirmed by his father’s occupation upon marriage. Sometime before 1860, the GOOD family were living around the Rathbarry area (Castlefreke). In 1865, John GOOD married Hannah Maria SHORTEN in Kinneigh. At the time his occupation was gamekeeper at Castlefreke. After leaving Castlefreke, the GOOD family moved back to Ballineen where they ran the Post Office. Only some history of John & Hannah’s children is known:

·      Thomas GOOD (1863-bef 1871) – baptism would infer a pre-marriage child;

·      Anne/Annie GOOD (1867) = John WILLNECKER in 1892 Cork;

·      Maria GOOD (1870-bef 1876);

·      Thomas GOOD (1871) at home in Ballineen in 1901 & 1911;

·      Eliza GOOD (1873-1873);

·      Eliza Jane GOOD (1875) married a MACQUIRE, then as a widow married Arthur Bowring WALLING in 1914 South Africa;

·      Marie GOOD (1876) – at home in Ballineen in 1901;

·      Margaret GOOD (1877) – no history;

·      James GOOD (1879-c1880) – no history, death based on family stories;

·      Gertrude Hannah “Gertie” GOOD (c1882-1923), my wife’s GGM;

·      John “Jack” GOOD (1881-1958) employed with the British High Commission in Cape Town, South Africa. He married Catherine Dorothy “Cassie” LYONS in 1902 Johannesburg and the couple had a daughter Kathleen Margaret GOOD (1909). After a divorce, John married Florence Eileen MILLER in 1928. John died in Pretoria;

·      Emily GOOD (1884) - at home in Ballineen in 1911;

William GOOD is not known from any baptism, but again from his marriage in 1862 to Frances FORD of Ballinascarthy at Kilmacabea (father – Thomas (Labourer), witness - John GOOD, his brother). William & Frances started their lives together in Rosscarbery, but later moved on via Timoleague & Bandon, Cork and then Tralee in Kerry by 1878. At the time of his marriage, William was a shepherd. Their children:

·      Thomas GOOD (1864 Rosscarbery);

·      Anne GOOD (1865 Rosscarbery);

·      George GOOD (1867 Rosscarbery);

·      Mary Jane GOOD (1869 Rosscarbery);

·      John GOOD (1871 Timoleague);

·      Un-named son (1873 Bandon);

·      Elizabeth G GOOD (1875 Cork);

·      James William GOOD (Tralee, Kerry);


Part 3: The SHORTEN Family of Moneygaff West, County Cork

Hannah Maria SHORTEN, my wife’s 2xGGM, is part of the original family of C17th English Protestant settlers who arrived from Devon/Somerset along with the GOODs and many other families. There are numerous examples of GOOD = SHORTEN marriages in the C19th. At the time of Griffiths Valuation (see map) the SHORTEN / SHORTIN families where highly concentrated in West Cork. The SHORTENs can be found in records referring to Moneygaff West (Moneygoff), Ballineen and Kinneigh:

 

The head of my wife’s SHORTEN family is James Paul SHORTEN (c1799-1887), my wife’s 3xGGF. He was a farmer at Moneygaff West. In 1833 he married my wife’s 3xGGM Mary HARROLD (1816-1904). Their children were baptised at the original church at Ballymoney (Ballineen):

·      Tamar SHORTEN (1831) – noting that Tamar is a widely-used family name = Nicholas WHITE in 1859;

·      Eliza SHORTEN (1833-1865) = John BUTTIMER in 1861;

·      Paul SHORTEN (1834-1893) = Mary Ann BATEMAN in 1875. Paul’s early death was covered by the newspaper article below. His widow was left with 7 young children;

·      Hannah Maria SHORTEN (1841-1925), my wife’s 2xGGM = John GOOD;

·      Anne SHORTEN (1843);

·      Margaret SHORTEN (1843-1920) = another John GOOD of Phale;

·      Catherine SHORTEN (1853) = James KINGSTON in 1882 Rosscarbery;

 


Home Page & Contact Info

The outline above is indicative only and not necessarily fully correct or complete. It should be used for guidance only.
The CreativeGraces family tree can be found on Ancestry.

 

https://www.creativegraces.net/images/cglogo.jpg